Before Your Next Career Move: Compensation, Benefits, Taxes and Retirement

Finance · Career & Money

Salary is only one number. Here is what else to review before you accept an offer or give notice.

General educational information only. It is not individualized financial, tax, investment, or legal advice.

Planning the financial side of a career move: compensation, benefits, taxes and retirement
Compensation, retirement accounts, taxes and benefits all deserve a look before a career move.

A new job with a higher salary is not automatically a better financial deal. Salary is usually the first number people compare when considering a career move, but the actual financial impact can be much broader. Bonuses, retirement contributions, health insurance, stock compensation, deferred compensation, paid time off and other benefits can materially change what a new position is worth.

Leaving a job creates another set of decisions. What happens to the old 401(k)? Are stock options affected? Does insurance coverage end immediately? Could a severance package change taxable income for the year? Good career transition planning looks at all of it before the decision is made.

Quick read

Key Takeaways: The Financial Side of Changing Jobs

  • A higher salary does not automatically mean a better total compensation package.
  • Retirement plan options should be reviewed when leaving an employer.
  • Bonuses, severance and stock compensation can create unusual tax situations.
  • Equity compensation may be subject to vesting rules and post-employment deadlines.
  • Health, life and disability insurance may change during a career transition.
  • A new position can affect retirement savings and retirement timing.
  • Coordinated financial planning can help evaluate the complete impact of a career move.

Start With Total Compensation, Not Salary

Suppose someone earns $175,000 and receives an offer for $200,000. At first, the decision looks easy. But the current employer may provide a stronger retirement match, better health coverage, a large annual bonus or equity compensation. The new position might have a higher salary but shift more healthcare costs to the employee.

The opposite could be true. A modest salary increase might come with substantially better benefits and a compensation structure that creates greater long-term value. This is why a new offer should be evaluated as a complete compensation package. Salary matters, but so do bonuses, retirement benefits, insurance, stock options, restricted stock, deferred compensation and other employer benefits.

The question isn't just, "What will I make?" It is, "What am I actually gaining and what am I giving up?"

Worksheet

Compare the Complete Compensation Package

Using the example above, only the two salary figures are known. Every other line is something to gather and compare.

Current position

  • Base salary: $175,000
  • Annual bonus: To compare
  • Employer retirement contributions: To compare
  • Health insurance: To compare
  • Equity compensation: To compare
  • Deferred compensation: To compare
  • Paid time off: To compare
  • Other benefits: To compare

New position

  • Base salary: $200,000
  • Signing or annual bonuses: To compare
  • Employer retirement contributions: To compare
  • Health insurance costs: To compare
  • Equity compensation: To compare
  • Deferred compensation: To compare
  • Paid time off: To compare
  • Other benefits: To compare

A salary increase on its own does not show which package has the greater overall financial value.

Don't Leave the Old Retirement Plan Behind Mentally

Changing employers often leaves a retirement account behind. The money doesn't disappear, but the account can easily become something that receives very little attention for the next decade.

Depending on the circumstances and plan rules, someone leaving an employer may have several options for an old workplace retirement plan. They may be able to leave assets in the former employer's plan, move them into a new employer's eligible plan, roll them into an IRA or take a distribution.1 Those choices aren't interchangeable.

Taxes, investment options, fees, creditor protections, access to funds and the person's broader retirement strategy can all matter. Cashing out a retirement account can also create taxes and, depending on the person's age and circumstances, potentially additional tax consequences. The important part is making an intentional decision rather than allowing an old account to become disconnected from the rest of your overall strategy.

Options to understand

What Can Happen to Your Old Retirement Plan?

  • Leave the assets in the former employer's plan, if permitted.
  • Move eligible assets into a new employer's plan, if permitted.
  • Roll eligible assets into an IRA.
  • Take a distribution.

Each option may carry different tax, fee, investment, access and creditor protection considerations. Not every option is available to every person, and plan rules and individual circumstances apply.

A Career Change Can Create Tax Surprises

Career changes can produce unusual income years. Someone might receive a final bonus from one employer and a signing bonus from another. Severance may be paid. Stock compensation may vest, or options may be exercised. Accrued vacation could be paid out. Now add the salary from the new employer, and income can look very different from a normal year.

That can affect withholding and estimated tax needs. It can also influence other financial decisions being considered during the same period. This is one reason career change financial opportunities should be evaluated alongside potential tax consequences. A large payment may create an opportunity to increase savings, pay down debt or invest more, but the amount deposited into a bank account isn't necessarily the amount available to spend.

Understanding the tax impact first can prevent an unpleasant surprise later.

Equity Compensation Needs Special Attention

Stock options and other forms of equity compensation can make a career transition more complicated. Before leaving an employer, understand what happens to vested and unvested awards. Some unvested compensation may be forfeited. Vested options may have an exercise deadline after employment ends. Restricted stock and other awards can operate under different rules.

This is not an area where assumptions are useful. Read the plan documents and employment agreement. Understand the dates and find out what changes when employment ends. For executives and employees with substantial equity compensation, it can make sense to involve a financial advisor and tax professional before giving notice. Once employment ends or a deadline passes, some choices may no longer be available.

Benefits Can Be Worth More Than They Look

Health insurance deserves more attention during a job change than it usually gets. Find out when coverage from the old employer ends and when the new coverage begins because there can be a gap. The U.S. Department of Labor recommends comparing health coverage when changing jobs and provides information about options that may be available following the loss of employer-sponsored coverage.2

Then compare the plans themselves. Premiums are only one number. Deductibles, out-of-pocket limits, employer contributions to health savings accounts and coverage for family members can change the actual cost considerably.

Life and disability insurance should also be reviewed. Employer-provided coverage can disappear when a job ends. If a family depends heavily on someone's income, discovering after the transition that important coverage disappeared is not ideal. Career transition planning should include a benefits inventory before leaving, not after.

Benefits inventory

Benefits to Review Before Changing Jobs

  • Health insurance premiums
  • Deductibles
  • Out-of-pocket limits
  • Health savings account contributions
  • Family coverage
  • Life insurance
  • Disability insurance
  • Coverage start and end dates

Compare the date your current coverage ends with the date the new coverage begins, so a possible gap does not catch you off guard.

Your Retirement Timeline May Have Changed

A major career move can affect when retirement becomes realistic. A large compensation increase might allow someone to save more aggressively. A buyout or severance package later in a career could make an earlier retirement possible. Moving into consulting or part-time work might provide income while delaying withdrawals from retirement accounts.

A lower-paying position can work too, especially if it is intentional. Someone in their late 50s may decide that less income is worth more flexibility, but the financial impact should be calculated first. What happens to retirement contributions? Healthcare coverage? Social Security earnings? The amount that will eventually need to come from investments?

The answer may confirm that the move is affordable. Or it may show that working another year or adjusting spending makes the transition considerably easier. That's useful information to have before resigning.

Possibilities, not predictions

How a Career Move Can Affect Retirement

Higher compensation

Potential opportunity to increase savings and retirement contributions.

Lower compensation

May require reviewing savings goals, spending and retirement timing.

Consulting or part-time work

May provide continued income while changing benefits and retirement contributions.

Severance or buyout

May affect the timing of retirement and require careful tax and income planning.

These are possible outcomes, not guaranteed ones. Every situation depends on individual numbers.

Career Change Financial Opportunities Are Easy to Miss

Not every financial consequence of changing jobs is negative. A transition can be a useful time to reorganize finances. There may be an opportunity to increase retirement contributions, reconsider investment allocations, consolidate accounts, build additional cash reserves or finally review insurance and estate documents that haven't been touched in years.

A higher income may create room to increase savings without affecting current spending very much. A temporary period between jobs can also change the tax picture enough to make certain planning strategies worth discussing with an advisor and tax professional.

The point isn't to make every career transition into a financial project. It is to recognize that changing employment creates a natural point to review the plan.

Checklist

Financial Tasks Worth Reviewing During a Career Transition

  • Retirement contribution levels
  • Investment allocations
  • Old retirement accounts
  • Cash reserves
  • Insurance coverage
  • Beneficiary designations
  • Estate documents
  • Tax planning
  • Long-term savings goals

This Is a Good Time to Use a Financial Advisor

Career decisions involve enough variables that trying to evaluate everything independently can become difficult. The new employer explains its benefits. The old employer explains what happens when you leave. A CPA looks at taxes. Retirement plan administrators explain their particular accounts. But someone still needs to look at the whole picture.

A financial advisor can compare the old and new compensation packages, review retirement accounts, examine how the move affects savings goals and retirement projections, and help identify questions that need to go to a tax or legal professional. This is particularly useful when a transition involves substantial compensation, equity awards, severance, a buyout or a possible early retirement.

Fragasso Wealth Advisors, a Pittsburgh wealth management firm, addresses many of these issues in its career transition planning resource. The resource discusses compensation changes, retirement plans, stock options, benefits, taxes and the effect a career move can have on someone's retirement horizon.

The broader lesson applies regardless of which advisor someone chooses. Get advice before the move when possible, not six months afterward.

Career transition planning resource

Promotional

Explore Career Transition Planning with Fragasso Wealth Advisors

Fragasso Wealth Advisors, a Pittsburgh wealth management firm, provides educational resources discussing compensation changes, retirement plans, stock options, employee benefits, tax considerations, and how a career move can affect long-term retirement goals.

Explore the Career Transition Resource

Educational resource from the advisory firm discussed in this article. General information only, not personalized advice.

Look at What the Career Move Changes

A career change is rarely just a change in paycheck. It can alter taxes, benefits, insurance, retirement savings and the amount of financial risk a household can comfortably take. Later in a career, it may even change the retirement date.

So, compare the salary, of course, but then keep going. Look at the retirement plan, understand the benefits, review stock compensation and estimate the tax impact. Decide what happens to old accounts and run the retirement numbers again. When several of those decisions overlap, a financial advisor can help coordinate them and identify issues that may be easy to miss when each decision is considered separately.

The best time to understand the financial consequences of a career move is while there are still choices available, not after the transition is complete.

Before you decide

Before You Accept the Offer, Review the Full Financial Picture

A career move can affect much more than salary. Compensation, benefits, retirement accounts, taxes, insurance, equity awards and long-term financial goals may all change. The best time to evaluate those consequences is before the transition, while there are still choices available.

Career ChangeRetirement PlanningTotal CompensationEquity CompensationMore in Finance